If you’ve ever searched “HomeAdvisor roofing Boise” or “Angie’s List roofers Boise,” you’re not alone, but can you trust these sources?
When your roof starts leaking, or a storm rolls through the Treasure Valley, you might find yourself in a predicament. You need roofing help, perhaps a few shingles are missing, but where do you turn?
Oftentimes, these platforms like HomeAdvisor or Angie’s List feel like a quick shortcut to finding a contractor. But like many Boise homeowners, you might find yourself asking this question:
Can I actually trust HomeAdvisor or Angie’s List to send me a quality roofer… or am I just being sold as a new lead?
Let’s break down how these platforms work, what they do well, and where they can fall short, especially for roofing projects in Boise’s unique climate.
How HomeAdvisor & Angie’s List Really Work
At their core, HomeAdvisor and Angie’s List are paid lead-generation platforms. Companies that offer services from HVAC to plumbing, siding to roofing, pay to be listed on their platforms and receive leads. It is free for homeowners like you to use, but local Boise companies must pay a fee for each lead.
Essentially, roofing companies:
- Pay to be listed
- Pay for homeowner leads
- Often compete with several other contractors for the same request
That means when you submit your info, multiple roofers may receive it at once, regardless of their skill level, experience, or understanding of Boise-specific roofing challenges like snow load, ice dams, or extreme summer heat.
Being listed doesn’t automatically mean they’re the best roofer for your home; it often means they paid to be there. So simply put, it is a pay-to-play game! This might lead to the next logical question: Can I trust these types of lead aggregator platforms, and do they qualify their contractors?
Do Angie’s List and HomeAdvisor Lead Platforms Vet Contractors?
Real quick, if you type in “Roofer Near Me” or “Angie’s List Roofing,” you will instantly see lead aggregator platforms. As mentioned earlier, these platforms collect subscriptions from contractors for various services, then sell leads to them.
The logical question is: can you trust these contractors, and do these platforms vet or qualify them?
The short answer is: Yes… but only at a basic level.
Here is how it works. Most contractors who want to use listings are checked for:
- Business registration
- Insurance (sometimes self-reported)
- License status
While that isn’t a bad thing, the issue is what’s often not verified, which can range from a variety of factors, such as:
- Quality of workmanship
- Local roofing experience in Boise
- Proper installation methods for Idaho weather
- How often does the company use subcontractors
- Long-term warranty follow-through
In the roofing industry, the last bullet point – warranties for roofs – is vital when picking a contractor. Your roof’s warranty is dependent on proper installation and the submission of paperwork. So while you may see a roofer with reviews, that doesn’t guarantee they specialize in the roofing conditions in the Treasure Valley or stand behind their work after the job is done… even if you find them on a lead platform!
Why Reviews on Angie’s Can Be Misleading
Many homeowners searching for the best HomeAdvisor roofers in Boise or Angie’s List rely heavily on star ratings, but there’s a catch. These platforms collect reviews, which can be helpful for you, the consumer, but here is what they don’t tell you:
- Some reviews are from small repair jobs, not full roof replacements
- Some are years old and no longer reflect current crews
- Contractors can be removed—or promoted—based on payment tiers
- Negative experiences don’t always make it onto the platform
A company might look great online, but still cut corners on underlayment, ventilation, or flashing, things that matter a lot in Boise’s freeze-thaw cycles, but you will never see that on a review. Additionally, some reviews are simply inaccurate or do not show the whole picture, which is why some people say they can be misleading.
Then there is the fast-response “blow up your phone” issue…
The “Fast Response” Problem
Another issue homeowners like the one in the screenshot above on Reddit mention is the emphasis of HomeAdvisor and Angie’s List on speed over quality. Because contractors pay per lead, the fastest one to call often wins the job, but that also means you will get blown up.
Many users complain about the number of calls, texts, and emails they get because, remember, these roofing contractors are paying for the leads. You are not getting the most qualified, but the hungriest in most cases!
That urgency can pressure homeowners into decisions before they’ve had time to:
- Compare warranties
- Understand material options
- Verify local references
- Ask about attic ventilation or ice-and-water shield
A rushed roofing decision for your roof repair or new roof can lead to expensive problems down the road. We recently replaced a roof that was under 3 years old!
Are HomeAdvisor & Angie’s List Useless?
Overall, HomeAdvisor and Angie’s List are not useless; they have a solid reputation, and as billion brands, they have the clout. That said, they shouldn’t be your only filter.
These platforms can be a starting point, but the more expensive the service, the deeper you might want to dig, so to speak. For example, if you need a quick faucet repair or HVAC tune-up, Angie’s List is great.
However, if you are getting something like a new roof or, let’s say, hardscaping work done, you want to slow down and do your own research and consider:
- Ask how long the roofer has worked specifically in the Treasure Valley
- Request local addresses they’ve roofed—not just reviews
- Confirm they follow Idaho wind and snow load standards
- Ask who will actually be on your roof
- Review warranty coverage beyond “manufacturer only.” What is the roofing labor warranty
A Better Way to Choose a Local Boise Company
If you can only trust local home service directories as far as you can throw them, then what is the best way to find a roofer or local service company near you? First, start with the things that matter:
- Rely on reputation, not lead buying
- Have long-standing Boise roots
- Offer free, pressure-free inspections
- Educate homeowners instead of rushing them (see our blog)
Instead of relying solely on paid directories, many homeowners prefer working with local roofing companies that don’t cut corners and are honest. The best way to find a roofer or company like this in the Treasure Valley is to start with word-of-mouth, search, and reviews.
From there, it is always best to get multiple opinions and ultimately decide with your gut instincts when it comes to more expensive projects like new roofs or window replacements!
Final Thought on Angie’s & HomeAdvisor
If you’re wondering whether you can trust HomeAdvisor or Angie’s List roofers in Boise, the honest answer is:
They’re a tool—but not a guarantee.
The best roofing decisions come from transparency, local expertise, and contractors who earn trust the hard way by doing a great job every time. Here at Legacy Roofing of Idaho, we do not personally list our services on these home directories.
We have found if you want a second opinion or a straight-talk inspection from someone who actually understands Boise roofs, that’s always worth the conversation… and we are ready to have it with you!
Just reach out below to get your free roof inspection or ask us any questions!
9 Most Popular Types of Shingles for Your Home!