When you Google “pros and cons asphalt shingles,” you’re instantly inundated with the same tired perspectives – uniform lists detailing the affordability, easy installation of asphalt shingles, and their status as a go-to roofing material.
After all, the asphalt shingle roofing industry has done a stellar job advertising its merits. But what if we told you there’s more beneath the surface? Beyond the obvious asphalt shingle roof advantages, hidden pros and cons to always know before you replace your roof. With asphalt roofing materials, it’s not all black and white, but a spectrum of greys as intricate as the granular surface of an asphalt shingle.
In this article, we’re going to delve into the pros and cons as it pertains to asphalt shingle roofing!
The Quick History of Asphalt Shingles:
There’s a common myth that adopting asphalt shingles for roofing installations across America resulted from cost-effectiveness. While it’s true that the economic factor played a role, there’s a far more intriguing history to uncover that busts this myth.
Asphalt shingles didn’t merely slide into popularity because they were the cheapest choice. Instead, their evolution and success in the market weave a uniquely American tale, echoing the spirit of innovation and adaptation.
Asphalt Shingles Timeline
The Debut 1893
Asphalt shingles made their debut. Unlike today’s lightweight shingles, the original versions were heavy and difficult to install, a challenge that many a roofing contractor wrestled with. The debut of asphalt shingles offered an alternative to the often expensive and fire-prone wood shingles that were popular at the time.
The early 1900s
Asphalt shingles began gaining recognition as a viable option for roof coverage, not just patchwork. Yet, the struggle to install asphalt shingles efficiently remained a hurdle.
In this era, manufacturers started adding mineral granules to the surface of the shingles, enhancing their durability and weather resistance. This innovative step marked a turning point for asphalt shingles, starting their journey toward becoming one of the most popular roofing materials.
The invention of strip shingles, or what we now call architectural shingles, presented an even more attractive, easy-to-install option. These multi-layered shingles replicated the appearance of traditional wood or slate shingles, further boosting their appeal.
Late 20th century to present
Asphalt shingles have continuously evolved, incorporating fiberglass for increased strength, and offering a wide range of colors and styles. They’ve become the go-to choice for new roof installations in the United States and are seen as the perfect roofing material for many homeowners.
Fun Fact: Today, asphalt shingles cover more than 70% of American roofs, a testament to their evolution from a cumbersome, basic roofing option to a versatile, reliable, and aesthetically pleasing solution.
Pros: Advantages of Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are as synonymous with American homes as the white picket fence, the vibrant lawns, and Hollywood’s depiction of suburban life. They’ve served as a backdrop to countless real and fictional stories, sheltering everything from humble abodes to luxurious mansions across the nation. But their popularity isn’t rooted in just pop culture.
Instead, the unique advantages asphalt shingles bring have etched them into the heart of the American roofing landscape.
- Affordability: When compared to other roofing materials, asphalt shingles reign supreme in terms of cost-effectiveness. It’s not just the initial cost of the shingles themselves, but the entire installation process that ends up being more economical. The ease and speed at which roofing contractors can install asphalt shingles translate to lower labor costs and quicker completion times.
- Variety: Asphalt shingle roofing offers an extensive range of styles, colors, and textures. From traditional 3-tab shingles to high-end architectural or luxury shingles, homeowners can customize their roofs to match the aesthetic of their homes. This design flexibility is hard to find in other roofing materials.
- Durability: Despite their affordability, asphalt shingles don’t skimp on performance. They can withstand various weather conditions and have decent longevity. Many manufacturers also offer warranties, further solidifying their reliability.
- Ease of Installation and Repair: The installation process for asphalt shingles is relatively straightforward, which reduces the risk of installation errors. Additionally, if damage does occur, individual shingles can be replaced without the need to overhaul the entire roof, making repairs simpler and more cost-effective.
The advantages of asphalt shingles extend far beyond mere cost-effectiveness. They represent a blend of economy, aesthetics, durability, and ease, making them a trusted partner in sheltering American homes.
Whether in the glaring sunshine of California or under the snow-laden skies of Maine, asphalt shingles have proven their worth. They are more than just a roofing material; they are a piece of the American lifestyle.
See and learn more about the Legacy Roofing roof replacement process!
Learn about the pricing model and cost guide for a new roof!
Get to know more about the most frequently asked roofing questions!
Cons: Disadvantages of Asphalt Shingles
Let’s pull back the veil of American suburbia for a moment and take a hard, critical look at our trusted friend, the asphalt shingle roof. While it’s no doubt an affordable roofing material and offers plenty of perks, it isn’t devoid of drawbacks. Understanding the cons of asphalt shingle roofing is essential to making an informed decision. So let’s jump right into the other side of the story.
- Shorter Lifespan: While asphalt roofing is undeniably budget-friendly, it does come at the expense of longevity. Compared to roofing materials such as metal or tile, asphalt shingles fall short, often needing replacement in as little as 15 to 20 years.
- Environmental Impact: The manufacturing process of asphalt shingles and their disposal at the end of life contribute to waste in landfills, like most construction materials. While recycling initiatives exist, they aren’t widespread.
- Weather Vulnerability: Despite the overall durability of asphalt shingles, they can be susceptible to severe weather conditions. High winds, heavy snowfall, or extreme heat can potentially cause damage, leading to the need for repairs or replacement.
- Aesthetic Limitations: While you can find asphalt shingles in various colors and designs, they might not offer the unique, high-end look that other materials like slate or cedar can provide. This can be a significant con of asphalt for homeowners looking to add a distinctive architectural element to their homes.
A Balanced Perspective: Not Just Good or Bad
Is there such a thing as a perfect roofing material? It’s tempting to think so, especially when you come across bold statements claiming one option superior to all others. But, like any major decision, choosing the right roofing for your home isn’t as black and white as it may seem.
It’s not about finding the absolute best but determining what’s best for you. Let’s take a step back from the bias and consider the bigger picture.
1. Consider the Climate
Different roofing materials excel in different climates. Asphalt shingles, for example, perform well in a variety of conditions but might falter in extreme weather, while metal roofing can withstand high winds and heavy snow but may be less efficient in coastal areas due to potential rusting.
2. Think Long-Term
Installation asphalt shingles may be more affordable upfront, but if you plan on living in your home for many decades, investing in a longer-lasting material like metal or slate could save you from future replacement costs.
3. Style and Aesthetics Matter
The look of your roof can dramatically impact your home’s curb appeal. A wood shake roof, for example, might offer an organic, rustic charm that asphalt shingles can’t mimic. Conversely, the sleek, uniform look of asphalt might suit a modern home better.
A metal roof or slate roof will cost more money but offer more in aesthetics.
4. Factor in Maintenance
Some roofing materials require more maintenance than others. Asphalt shingles tend to be low maintenance, while a wood shake roof might need regular cleaning and treatment to prevent rot and insects.
5. Weigh Environmental Impact
If sustainability is a priority for you, consider the lifecycle of the roofing material—from its manufacturing process to disposal or recyclability.
Navigating the world of roofing options can feel overwhelming, but a balanced approach will help ensure your decision aligns with your specific needs, preferences, and circumstances. Rather than asking, “Which is the best roofing material,” perhaps the better question is, “Which is the best roofing material for me?
The Final Word on Asphalt Shingle Roofing –
Choosing the right roof is more than a practical consideration—it’s a commitment, an investment in the shelter that will cradle your dreams and withstand the storms of life. Asphalt shingles, like all roofing options, have their pros and cons, charms, and challenges.
Perhaps the question isn’t “Are asphalt shingles good or bad?” but, rather, “Are they right for me and my home?” Because, in the end, your roof is more than just a component of your house—it’s the crown that completes your castle. And who wouldn’t want their castle to be perfect, down to the last shingle?