What is the Best Roofing Shingle on the Market in 2025?

Are you wondering what the best roofing shingle is on the market now? Whether you live in Boise, Nampa, or elsewhere in the United States, Legacy Roofing of Idaho loves shingles and roofs!

We want to help you choose the best roofing shingles possible for your home. Roof shingles not only protect your house but can also enhance its appearance. With so many roofing shingles and roofing manufacturers, selecting the most popular roofing materials is crucial, but you want to consider all the factors!

Stay tuned as we explore what makes sure roof shingles stand out in 2025. Keep reading to learn more below!

What are the best shingles?

Let’s get right to the point about shingles. Picking the best shingle will ultimately depend on your budget and what look you desire; however, the most common shingle is asphalt. Specifically, architectural shingles are the most popular shingles currently being installed across the United States.

Architectural shingles are an upgrade to their 3-tab counterparts. They provide durability, affordability, and curb appeal. Keep reading as we explain more in-depth why architectural asphalt shingles are the top pick by most homeowners and roofing contractors.

➡️The Verdict: Asphalt roof shingles provide what most homeowners need for their roofs. Everything else may add aesthetics, longer durability, or eco-friendly results; however, these typically come at a premium cost.

2025 Roof Shingle Trends: Discover What’s Trending!

2025 is shaping up to be a groundbreaking year for roofing, blending technology and style seamlessly. With green initiatives and keeping durability in mind, just like everything, roofing shingles have technological advancements, too.

Here are some of the most current roofing trends:

1. Smart Roofing Solutions

The rise of “Smarter” roofing is making waves, with solar shingles making a significant impact. These advanced systems integrate technology into your roof, allowing homeowners to track and manage smartphone energy use. This tech-savvy approach is convenient and boosts your home’s energy efficiency—things like solar panels, solar shingles, and even roofing material technological advancements help.

2. Impact-Resistant Shingles

Ever heard of hail damage to a roof? Believe it or not, it is widespread. Hail damage can lead to many issues with your home’s shingles and require a roof replacement. Here in the Treasure Valley, we have tons of hail damage calls yearly, and the best roof shingles provide more protection. Composite shingles, synthetic shingles, and proven shingle brands produce stronger ones for your home.

Durability is critical in choosing roofing materials, and many homeowners around Boise are turning to impact-resistant asphalt roofing shingles. These robust shingles are built to endure severe weather conditions like hail and heavy storms, ensuring your roof remains intact and functional for years.

3. Weather-proof and Stylish Roofs

2025 also sees a trend towards asphalt shingles that combine sturdy weather resistance with serious style. Manufacturers like GAF and Owens Corning are innovating with luxury and architectural shingles that offer top-tier protection and dramatically enhance the visual appeal of any home.

4. Simplified Metal Roofing

Black metal roofing simplifies the old-school complex metal choices into sleek, stylish designs. These quickly become favorites for their modern look and strong performance in residential and commercial settings.

5. Accessible Eco-Friendly Roofs

Green roofing is finally hitting the mainstream with more practical, eco-friendly options. Brands are expanding their offerings with features like garden-ready rooftops and recycled materials, pushing the sustainable building movement forward.

With a clear shift towards innovative solutions, asphalt shingles and architectural shingles are leading the way, helping homes and businesses alike meet contemporary standards of efficiency and aesthetics.

The Best Asphalt Shingles on The Market in 2025

Now that you know that Archteicrual Asphalt Shingles are the best shingles on the market, what makes them the best? A shingle roof might seem like a pretty simple concept when you replace your roofing system. However, there are shingle brands and materials that will enhance your roof.

When it comes to shingles, the top-tier choices protect not only your wallet but also your home! So when you get a new roof, be sure to consider the following regarding architectural asphalt shingles:

• Advanced Protection: The latest architectural asphalt shingle technology is makes them tougher than a two-dollar steak. Ideal for both residential and commercial roofing products, architectural shingles offer superior durability and longevity. They are much heavier, and the composition of the shingles makes them last longer.
• Cost-Effective: Asphalt shingles remain the most economically savvy roofing material, providing excellent protection without the premium price tag. Metal roofs, slate tiles, and other roofing materials may be more durable or last longer, but they are often two times more than an asphalt shingle roof.
• Stylish Options: Architectural asphalt shingles come in various styles and colors, enhancing your home’s curb appeal. Unlike the traditional three-tab shingles, which were known to be boring and bland, architectural asphalt shingles blend different granular colors that give a wood shake look without the wood shake issues!
• Energy Efficiency: Keep cool without the high bills. Believe it or not, asphalt shingles can reflect solar heat, reducing cooling costs and improving your home’s energy efficiency. The shingle material and advanced technology help increase energy friendliness.

Questions about Archtietrual Shingles:

Some of the common questions to consider when picking a shingle our for your new roof:

• What’s your endgame with these shingles? Whether it’s boosting curb appeal with luxury shingles or just basic protection, there’s a roofing shingle tailored to your needs. Keep in mind how long you plan to live at your home.
• Keeping an eye on the budget? Asphalt shingles are your best friend here, providing top-notch protection without draining your wallet. Asphalt shingles are typically going to cost $3-$6 per square foot installed whereas metal roofs can cost $10 to $17 on average.
• Building code blues? Make sure your choice in shingle roofs complies with local regulations which might dictate or limit your options (HOA rules may state what shingles you can use).
• Worried about the weather? In areas prone to harsh conditions, look for roofing shingles that offer extra resistance to hail, severe winds, or pesky algae streaks.

Did you know? According to a survey by the US Department of Energy, a whopping 80% of homes across the USA have roofs decked out in asphalt roofing shingles. It seems like asphalt has won the roofing popularity contest!

With their durability and affordability, it’s no surprise that these roofing shingles are the top pick. Next time you’re out for a stroll, look up—you’re likely under the reliable protection of America’s best roofing shingles!

Selecting the right asphalt shingles for your roof!

Selecting the right asphalt shingle for your home isn’t as straightforward as picking a color for your bedroom—it’s about balancing several vital factors to find the best fit for your roof. Here’s what you should always consider:

1. Price: You want the best deal on your roof, just like shopping for a new car. Compare prices between roofing materials to find the best roofing shingles within your budget. Keep in mind that the cheapest option isn’t always the best when it comes to roofing shingles.
2. Quality: Not all roofing shingles are created equal. Look for roofing companies known for helping you pick the best shingles for your home. We do not install 3-tab shingles at Legacy Roofing because we only work with the best (architectural shingles and metal roofing materials).
3. Shingle Warranty: Longer warranties often signal a better product. Opt for manufacturers and roofing companies that offer comprehensive coverage for their asphalt shingle products. Up to 50-year manufacturer warranties come with the most reputable shingle companies (GAF, Owens Corning, etc).

Shingle Manufactures:

In most cases, the roofing materials you select for your home’s new roof will dictate which shingle manufacturers are the best fit. At Legacy Roofing, we work primarily with GAF shingles and Owens Corning. The top three roofing materials manufacturers are GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning. Interview a roofing contractor, and chances are they use one of the three.

With many wood shingles no longer being used, most asphalt shingle manufacturers offer a limited lifetime warranty, which can often be the difference between choosing a shingle and not. To learn more about our shingles, be sure to read this here.

GAF: As one of the largest roofing manufacturers in North America, GAF shingles are renowned for their reliability and broad selection, from 3-tab shingles to luxury GAF shingles. At Legacy Roofing of Idaho, we use GAF timberline shingles for most projects. The wind resistance and composite materials make them one of the best options in the entire roofing industry. It isn’t hard to find GAF shingles since they emphasize sustainability and energy efficiency, making them a top choice for eco-conscious homeowners.

• PRO: Wide variety and strong contractor network.
• CON: Some product lines are pricier.

Owens Corning: Founded in 1938, Owens Corning is a stalwart in producing high-quality roof shingles, including durable 3-tab shingles. They are particularly noted for their innovative color and design options, which have set trends in residential roofing across the United States.

• PRO: Innovative shingle technology and strong warranties.
• CON: Premium pricing compared to some rivals.

CertainTeed: Known for premium roofing materials, including architectural shingles and wood shakes. CertainTeed stands out with a robust offering of high-performance and aesthetically appealing roofing options. They offer one of the best warranties in the industry, reassuring homeowners of their investment.

• PRO: Offers some of the highest quality and aesthetics.
• CON: Higher cost and selective availability.

Malarkey: Specializes in innovative and eco-friendly roof shingles. Malarkey focuses on utilizing smog-reducing granules in their shingles, which helps to clean the air, making them a leader in environmentally responsible roofing solutions.

• PRO: Focus on sustainability and energy-efficient products.
• CON: Limited distribution network.

TAMKO: Offers a variety of roof shingles, known for their vibrant color options and wood shakes. TAMKO’s products are engineered for weather resistance and long-lasting durability, appealing to homeowners looking for longevity and aesthetic flexibility.

• PRO: Good balance of performance and cost.
• CON: Warranties are not as competitive.

Atlas provides a wide range of shingles and is known for incorporating technology to prevent algae growth. Their products often come with Scotchgard Protector, which helps maintain the roof’s aesthetic quality by avoiding unsightly black streaks.

• PRO: Cost-effective and durable.
• CON: Fewer high-end options.

IKO: This global leader offers a wide array of roofing products, including architectural shingles. They are celebrated for their quality and strong focus on providing durable roofing solutions that can withstand extreme weather conditions, making them popular in varied climates worldwide.

• PRO: Competitive pricing and quality.
• CON: Variability in customer reviews regarding durability.

Each of these top roofing manufacturers has its own history and unique selling points, making the choice one of preference based on your specific roofing needs.

Final Thoughts on Shingle Roofs

Luxury shingles, designer shingles, asphalt shingles, solar shingles, metal roofs – and so on. We can see how navigating the roofing world resembles solving chemistry problems with your high school student. It is our hope this article helped you figure out the following:

1. The best shingle for your home
2. A rough pricing estimate when purchasing shingles
3. The manufacturers of shingles
4. Which roofing material is best for you & what shingle styles match your desires?

Here at Legacy Roofing, we have helped install nearly 600 roofs in the Treasure Valley in the last four years, and we are ready to help you with any questions you might have. Simply reach out below!